Brookline Educators Union

  • Home
    • About the BEU
    • Leadership
      • Officers
      • Consultants / Committee Chairs
      • Executive Board
      • Grievance Team
      • Building Representative Council
      • Health & Safety Committee
    • Contact
  • Negotiations Blog
  • News
    • BEU Newsletter
    • Solidarity Bulletins
    • Outside Press
    • Galleries
  • Parents & Community
    • Information
    • Allies
    • Community Events
  • Member Discussion
  • Documents
    • Contracts
    • Member Information and Forms
    • BEU Bylaws
  • First-Time Login?

Presentation of BEU Unit A proposals to the School Committee 01/10/2021

January 10, 2022

Common Planning Time:

Last month, the School Committee issued the following public statement:  

” – when teachers aren’t in front of students, someone else needs to be with them.  That means additional hires.”  The BEU does not disagree; it is a fact that since well before Covid the schools have been understaffed for the level of service that is being delivered to students. If the community expects this level of service to continue, then corresponding investments in staffing must be made, or the community should be made aware that the district can no longer bear the cost of the resources necessary to provide these services or programming.

Our team heard from building Principals in a bargaining session that scheduling common prep time was difficult and while we are holding firm that this time is needed for educators, we would propose that the time could be implemented into building schedules no later than 6/30/2023 to take effect for the 2023-2024 school year.  While we know that Common Planning is crucial for grade level teams, teachers of specials, and related service providers / caseload educators to meet and plan curriculum, tiered intervention strategies, and brainstorm issues that arise for individuals or groups of students, we are willing to take the next school year to allow for necessary schedule and staffing adjustments.

 

Daily Prep Time:

As part of the public statement referenced above, the School Committee stated that its position on —“Fair workload” for language, art and music teachers”  is that – “when teachers teach fewer students, that also means additional hires.”  This is read by the team as acknowledgement that the current situation of teachers of specials and world language teachers is indeed UNFAIR.  Additionally, we are not in disagreement that this would mean more hires; if this is not something that the schools are able to do, then the town should be informed that the level of service to which they are accustomed will need to change.

Our team remains committed to securing a daily preparation period of no less than 45 minutes for every educator.  This change will make schedules more equitable throughout and across buildings.  It is more evident than ever before that educators need time each day to plan, breathe, conduct other “self care” exercises, and take a break, even if it is a short one.  

Commitment to Retention of Staff of Color:

At the Brookline School Committee meeting on 1/7/2022, this issue was thrust to the forefront of discussions around how our students see themselves represented in the buildings where they “live” every day.  Our team has crafted language that we think both expresses a tangible and measurable commitment to recruit and retain staff of color.  In this same public statement, we heard that “we do not need language in a specific employment contract to be strongly committed as a district to diversity, equity and inclusion.”  We are baffled by this position.  We see contract language as the very vehicle by which both parties can affirm their commitment to this valuable effort.  We look forward to hearing language that you would accept that could lead to a common understanding of what diversity and equity could look like in the Public Schools of Brookline, but absent such commitment, we will stand by the language we proposed in November, which in no way limits the judgment of the superintendent and is zero cost.

JLMC:

When we first began the discussions to the successor contract in early 2020, this team of BEU Negotiators had 15 pages of thoughtfully formulated proposals that addressed issues of scheduling and workload. After meeting with hundreds of members (and people in the community), we distilled a set of issues such as preparation time, caseload and class size, teaching minutes, expansion of “4+1” into departmentalized grade levels, duties, extra help opportunities, office hours, stipend administrative positions, and others.  

The concerns and solutions we presented were affirmed by the school committee as timely and legitimate. Yet we were told repeatedly that these issues were better addressed through administration than in a collective bargaining agreement.  While we insist that the parameters of working conditions do indeed belong in a contract because this ensures fairness, consistency, and transparency, we also appreciate that the people who work most closely with students understand directly how well schools are functioning well or not.  Recognizing the value in a collaborative process undertaken by a group of administrators and educators who work closely together in the buildings day to day, we devised a plan that can bring their shared experience to bear on the ever evolving challenges we are facing in our schools.  We thus proposed a Joint Labor-Management Committee that would examine work activity and generate a “bargaining blueprint” for the next round of contract negotiations. We think all aspects of the contract pertaining to workload, including stipends, are relevant. The resulting report will be a recommendation, not contractual obligations for the BSC or responsibilities for Brookline educators.  We are therefore standing with our last proposal on this JLMC.

Wage Proposal:

Lastly, we would like to bring you up to date on our research around wages that lead to our proposal of nine percent over the three year contract.  Again, I reference the public statement from last month stating “if we were to agree to the request of 9% over 3 years, that would translate into a salary increase of $2M for next year.  **That would mean cutting somewhere between 25 and 30 teachers – the equivalent of eliminating all of the K-8 classroom teachers at Driscoll, Heath, Lincoln or Runkle, or eliminating music at all K-8s.  It would mean larger class sizes, reduced program offerings, or both. ** Clearly, that level of staffing cut would be detrimental to Brookline schools, which is why the negotiators have offered 6%, which is still a financial stretch but is in keeping with what other contracts near us have settled for, thus keeping Brookline teachers as the highest-paid among our peer districts”  There is a lot here to unpack, and let’s start with the last statement.  We are not aware of any “peer districts” having been discussed during these negotiations.  Are the districts mentioned in the public statement what you would propose that we are using for comparable districts if we end up in mediation or fact finding?

If so, we take it to be your position that your list are truly peer districts.  We would submit for the bargaining record our own list of peer districts: Acton-Boxborough, Arlington, Belmont, Concord-Carlisle, Dedham, Dover-Sherborn, Lexington, Lincoln-Sudbury, Natick, Needham, Newton, Somerville, Waltham, Watertown, Wellesley, Weston, Westwood, Winchester. 

We included all of yours even though some would be a stretch in terms of “comparable” but the list above would be amenable to the BEU.  

If you are not presenting these formally and prepared to justify your points of comparison, we would expect a public retraction of the suggestion that you have presented these as part of negotiations at any point and allowed the BEU to formally question your choices.  Should there be a need to engage in this conversation, we have a list ready for consideration that includes all of the districts mentioned and some others that we think are more similar to Brookline.

Again referencing the SC public statement: it references “Brookline teachers as the highest paid among peer districts.”  The concept of “peer districts’ ‘ notwithstanding, our research places Brookline 2nd or 3rd among the districts chosen by the SC for pay early in an educator’s career and 7th or 8th among those districts in pay later on.  We used the most current salary data from Brookline AND from those districts rather than salary numbers from three years ago.  I don’t know if it was stated publicly in that communication or not, but there is a number north of $100,000 that is floating out there as average educator pay in Brookline. We calculated the actual average pay based on the “scattergram” data that you provided and it comes out to just under $91,000, not including longevity or other benefits.  We would appreciate a public correction IF there has been a statement regarding that number.  

The public statement, however, makes no mention of the current levels of inflation.  As of November 2021, inflation since the expiration of the last contract (Aug 31, 2020) stands at 6.9%.  This means that the 6% “COLA” referenced as the “committee’s offer” represents a cut in pay of almost 1% with another 18 months of inflation not yet on the books.  Some believe that inflation will indeed begin to recede, but unless it turns negative, which is not a notion that is being entertained, that number of nearly 7% will not come down, but MAY (if we are lucky) lessen the slope of its ascent.  Inflation lessens the buying power of money and this round has been most influenced by energy, housing, and food which are the bulk of educator expenses no matter where they are on the salary scales.  Brookline’ scales have traditionally been among the higher scales in the state, which is appropriate given the cost of living in the greater Boston region.   That is why we have limited our ask to maybe cover the cost of living / inflationary pressure on income and not asked for a raise.  Our proposal would put the average pay for educators in Brookline just over $100,000 if there are no retirements and no new hires next year.  If there were, that number would obviously go down.  With the level of work and expectations of the community, we would not expect that our pay should be effectively cut.

This brings us to the actual COLA ask; we feel that the 9% (three percent over each of the three years of the contract) is both affordable and appropriate; in truth, it’s actually a good deal for the district.  Each year, quite apart from 35% enrollment growth, the district embarks on new initiatives and endeavors while refusing to allow time in the teacher day for these to take place.  We have been remiss in not insisting that we be compensated for this expansion of services in the Brookline school system. Instead, we insisted that time be carved out of the day and workloads be adjusted in order to make these things happen.  Again, we have repeatedly been told that “collective bargaining agreements are not the place for these manageable workload protections.”  So Brookline has gotten all this great programming while we have not demanded that it be paid for.  The town has been expanding the school system offerings while setting educator COLA’s at low levels of inflation, and thus has not had to go to the residents for overrides.  Well now inflation is high, and we need COLA’s that reflect that.  We have also heard that “there is no money for these COLA’s”, and while we disagree, we can respect that the budgets for School Year 2021 and 2022 have been set.  

We also respect that the budget for next year is being worked on right now and we will insist here and moving forward that budgets reflect the priority that educators be paid minimally for the rate of inflation; and also for any and all additional programming that comes with each school year.  Brookline needs to make a decision about what it can offer students in town and what that actually costs; educators do the work to make the programming function, we will not also bear the cost of the programs on our backs any longer.  

To this end, we remain firm at 9% over three years, but recognizing current budget commitments we would offer the following redistribution to our previous proposals:

YEAR ONE (2020-2021) 2% COLA retro to 9/1/2020

YEAR TWO (2021-2022) 2% COLA retro to 8/31/2021

YEAR THREE (2022-2023) 5% increase on ALL MONEY ITEMS IN THE CONTRACT

Year three involves a budget that has not been made yet, and we know that budgets are more than line items, they are statements of priorities.  

Our research has uncovered some “line items” that could be addressed to show that educators and education is a priority in Brookline.

  1. The difference between the 6% and 9% COLA proposals is about $2.6M over the life of the contract with most of that falling in the last year (2022-2023)   Over the past three years, Brookline has UNDERESTIMATED local receipts by an AVERAGE of almost $5.9M per year.  Should this pattern hold, half of this underestimation would fund the dollar difference in the two contract proposals.

 

  1. In our research, we looked at state reported finances of surrounding districts, including Brookline.  The average spending of “free cash” as a percentage of the operating budget was just over 7%.  Brookline’s was just over 4% putting it 11th out of 15 districts.  We looked at the same for “stabilization fund” dollars, and Brookline uses those monies for just over 2.5% of their budget while the average among the 15 districts is almost 6.5%, leaving Brooklne in 10th place. Brookline operates with debt as 5.9% of its budget placing it 11th (or 4th lowest) of these communities where the average community has debt as almost 10% of its budget.

 

Brookline is among the wealthiest municipalities in the commonwealth and current budget priorities are designed to facilitate three things. 

  1. Limit meaningful discussion of monetary priorities and additional expenditures by proscribing an arbitrary allocation of revenue through the school-town partnership.  
  2. Maintain low a property tax rate
  3. Maintain a Moody’s AAA bond rating before anything else.

 

The following data confirms the above and shows that there are untapped resources in town that would allow for full and robust funding of the schools and staff.  With over 80% of school funding going to staffing, there is no debate that Brookline schools ARE the educators, paraprofessionals, and administrators that make up the culture and “feel” of the building.  When we state that there is “wealth” in Brookline, it is because we know that:

  1. Brookline ranks 23rd out of 351 in per capita income ($95,466) according to the DOR
  2. Brookline ranks 27th out of 351 in property value per capita ($476,107)
  3. Yet Brookline ranks 313 out of 351 in terms of property tax rate (9.8%)
  4. Brookline has a prop 2.5 tax levy ceiling of over $700M.  Their actual tax levy is just shy of $275M.  What this means is that over the years since proposition two-and-a-half became law, Brookline property values have increased almost half a billion dollars more than taxes have been increased.  Brookline has a gap of almost 65% between what they could be taxing and what they are taxing under Prop 2 1/2.  That puts them 1st among the 15 communities referenced above in unused tax capacity, where the average “untaxed capacity” is 48%.  If the town is indeed “broke”, then it is by choice.

Filed Under: Featured News, Uncategorized Tagged With:

Log In


Lost your password?

Need Help Signing In

You can retrieve your password by following this link Retrieve Password

BEU Calendar

« February 2023 » loading...
S M T W T F S
29
30
31
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1
2
3
4
Mon 06

BEU Executive Board

February 6 @ 3:15 pm - 5:00 pm
Mon 13

BEU Reps Council

February 13 @ 3:15 pm - 4:45 pm
Mon 27

BEU Committees

February 27 @ 3:15 pm - 5:00 pm

MTA Info

Slideshow

71572985_10156527182556481_2961474637441007616_n
75340992_10156527182486481_5197738364710682624_n
75610779_10156527182431481_7222238012191539200_n
76705093_10156527182361481_580951325294985216_n
77200154_10156527182296481_2095998504928280576_n
75299781_10156527182241481_4811008913694523392_n
75627614_10156527182181481_4009689993332129792_n
78319007_10156527182086481_2934541198175502336_n
76779615_10156527182006481_4600587200164265984_n
78179402_10156527181926481_6567703352971362304_n
78045864_10156527181821481_7340512297602777088_n
75464267_10156527181751481_1819895600297017344_n
77318258_10156527181666481_4888432674231812096_n
77276017_10156527181611481_8390125678233649152_n
76647963_10156527181511481_4822376360687173632_n
75439241_10156527181426481_2614144089662160896_n
75569719_10156527181366481_7217270594750906368_n
75453544_10156527181311481_1311577609405988864_n
75394814_10156527181261481_6034144964563173376_n
78202874_10156527181176481_6314301665486831616_n
75593855_10156527181031481_4933908049954865152_n
77387958_10156527180966481_9190925324165054464_n
76695181_10156527180921481_6518092580872257536_n
75552940_10156527180771481_4429132496549969920_n
74328752_10156527180721481_7089642738152374272_n
73106913_10156527180641481_721401527582851072_n
77095163_10156527180566481_5310595171648274432_n
74989167_10156527180506481_8603826809747800064_n
76602147_10156527180416481_6754796595151110144_n
74185994_10156527180341481_1371592158095605760_n
74604757_10156527180196481_5602870573769162752_n
74169784_10156527180131481_8881237153963573248_n
75572083_10156527180061481_2332243301303844864_n
76686447_10156527179986481_338396586306437120_n
75380335_10156527179921481_8217248386961637376_n
75402150_10156527179841481_8823101730775367680_n
76697317_10156527179776481_4637793715870498816_n
75486021_10156527179706481_6981821080289673216_n
76756802_10156527179626481_7435463257034326016_n
77362202_10156527179541481_4601157086489870336_n
75472913_10156527179481481_1033752457248768000_n
76635068_10156527179276481_7071649878903881728_n
75102848_10156527179211481_3946248649150824448_n
73458832_10156527179161481_3635898341021188096_n
76710902_10156527179106481_4160953548881788928_n
75278253_10156527179051481_7460698023849361408_n
76697338_10156527179001481_8706999612189179904_n
75497654_10156527178911481_5192524471981834240_n
77015067_10156527178866481_4799429260957712384_n
75439500_10156527178781481_4959225082573488128_n
76654340_10156527178716481_1592310935458938880_n
76613075_10156527178631481_1142714385978884096_n
75271485_10156527178581481_5183944600498208768_n
73399913_10156527178516481_7474916663406624768_n
77380332_10156527178441481_790633273658179584_n
74505859_10156527178356481_6070150246636191744_n
75282174_10156527178276481_2620985903845212160_n
76769694_10156527178216481_246958549345763328_n
76602207_10156527178106481_106235659584274432_n
76195570_10156527178061481_4728173563083751424_n
77173198_10156527177961481_4228313969116315648_n
75341177_10156527177926481_6816645769185984512_n
77086468_10156527177861481_2482849572238393344_n
78549613_10156527177821481_1522192828392800256_n
76771526_10156527177691481_5267226760851750912_n
78228830_10156527177621481_8046835449139822592_n
76765485_10156527177541481_7603655834203062272_n
76905575_10156527177496481_1331044991056740352_n
72650894_10156527177446481_426676447915016192_n
75439387_10156529791796481_7605026216533295104_n
74906685_10156529791711481_4507321195057643520_n
75472800_10156529791621481_8273844695734419456_n
78324959_10156529791546481_4421978292215611392_n
76200953_10156529791461481_7810043851887869952_n
76604994_10156529791346481_7297806789238587392_n
76184068_10156529791251481_407966642660704256_n
76702356_10156529791141481_7145824419372335104_n
77050195_10156529791071481_6171278326817095680_n
76262118_10156529790946481_1521840576650018816_n
76646858_10156529790816481_7354573844436221952_n
76654443_10156529790711481_3955329172087242752_n
75653344_10156529790616481_8802692329652617216_n
77429104_10156529790511481_7189871576735547392_n
78378284_10156529790386481_7367155251050184704_n
77223478_10156529790331481_4072090100001931264_n
75540050_10156529790256481_2804853917643440128_n
75388427_10156529790171481_9131014529000407040_n
74458866_10156529790111481_5162929256799404032_n
76638469_10156529789951481_6601920893562126336_n
75594549_10156529789851481_2305702984689909760_n
78282726_10156529789681481_7478362043221803008_n
75594656_10156529789581481_411080395166056448_n
75429550_10156529789446481_7820025536272400384_n
78077156_10156529789326481_2266808070094979072_n
75302638_10156529789251481_1403549777089527808_n
75341222_10156529789091481_2310894792696922112_n
76640157_10156529788896481_5187039085780271104_n
74638368_10156529788741481_2188673874722291712_n
75310395_10156529788646481_155301962974232576_n
76204363_10156529788536481_5335884725066137600_n
77019497_10156529788476481_5122369432491917312_n
76605039_677150779359738_1323139730086297600_o-1
73513511_677150702693079_7154439286249488384_o
75543579_677150726026410_1967170754726330368_o-1
76757017_677150712693078_1666987196827041792_o
75439479_677152486026234_8272101604732174336_o-1
76652219_677151109359705_9001966794868523008_o-1
75424699_677151762692973_6641199739578613760_o-1
78104674_677152879359528_4127313814536323072_o-1
78156053_677153036026179_5985210482309464064_o-1
76901297_677150822693067_1623452734004920320_o-1
76769616_677151392693010_6148900232944943104_o-1
75594484_677151002693049_3594900335560228864_o
75580222_677151459359670_9125232089975750656_o-1
75449997_677152402692909_8725789007482454016_o
75485989_677151679359648_8845943724065161216_o-1
77317549_677151639359652_1249825755035074560_o-1
74522905_677152276026255_3648899829796438016_o
75462303_677151902692959_1485568976539877376_o
74649831_677152732692876_8738859679590907904_o-1
75627592_677152499359566_922905609106358272_o-1
75220761_677152439359572_2063443309954596864_o-1
75418843_677151629359653_1948648334600175616_o-1
77271149_677150926026390_1942882027472683008_o-1
77092671_677151212693028_3350264903960100864_o-1
75311432_677151326026350_646064824798674944_o-1
76258126_677151972692952_5463950530889908224_o-1
75323307_677152259359590_5835573615558393856_o-1
77426044_677151579359658_3781059156065124352_o-1
77303019_677151082693041_7258404497272078336_o-1
76622735_677151052693044_2451552738257928192_o-1
76693193_677151302693019_1328326912413532160_o-1
76695115_677151406026342_3487830601917005824_o-1
75317334_677150902693059_6471376011140268032_o-1
75398228_677153009359515_6207596827970109440_o-1
75349034_677151912692958_6976518741299298304_o-1
76993623_677152322692917_1402407135400165376_o-1
75299806_677152766026206_3274224732777480192_o-1
75481736_677151126026370_7359079823475474432_o-1
72473196_677152129359603_8274354491172585472_o-1
76197817_677152839359532_7247743241687138304_o-1
75576364_677152616026221_1383416542363910144_o-1
76720817_677151496026333_6749275161289031680_o-1
78058586_677151546026328_4808466159911305216_o-1
73250462_677152866026196_4072139462061064192_o-1
76972165_677152139359602_3188504963735093248_o-1
76756947_677151832692966_4240348420235067392_o-1
75231815_677152626026220_6538212453954617344_o-1
76967208_677152186026264_6984797290762338304_o-1
76267355_677152756026207_43375828205043712_o-1
77261230_677152602692889_6164321721043124224_o-1
75534259_677150932693056_5577135288645320704_o-1
76898914_677152369359579_5248627134393483264_o-1
69855955_677153019359514_8036579247625601024_o-1
76913759_677151282693021_5167290113188691968_o-1
76620889_677151786026304_8675767237077893120_o-1
78606874_677151029359713_2293491220141309952_o-1
76686507_10219715883508795_442342207983190016_o-1
IMG_1595
IMG_1594
IMG_1591
IMG_1592
IMG_1596
IMG_1597
IMG_1600
IMG_1598
IMG_1601
IMG_1603
IMG_1604
IMG_1605
IMG_1608
IMG_1609
IMG_1610
IMG_1611
IMG_1613
IMG_1614
IMG_1615
IMG_1616
IMG_1617
IMG_1621
IMG_1619
IMG_1622
IMG_1623
IMG_1627
IMG_1629
IMG_1630
IMG_1631
IMG_1632
IMG_1633

Categories

Archives

Latest Local Union News

  • BACK TO SCHOOL!
  • School Committee Forces BEU to Strike
  • Without Contract, Brookline Educators Authorize Strike for Monday, May 16
  • BEU submits counter-offer to School Committee on May 10, 2022

Follow Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

BEU Latest Tweets

  • I just signed a @theactionnet petition: Support Malden's Public School Educators. Sign here: https://t.co/5Z69rUhic9 September 16, 2022 11:09 am
  • Take the Pledge - NO CONTRACT NO COFFEE https://t.co/2l0fsbEf7y August 26, 2022 7:03 pm
  • https://t.co/FQgCItMr79 August 23, 2022 2:33 pm

RSS MTA News

  • Union News: Woburn educators fight for a fair contract January 31, 2023
  • Public statement per CERB order January 31, 2023
  • MTA Leadership: Woburn educators are 'adamant' that paraprofessionals earn a living wage January 30, 2023

RSS MTA Events

  • CANCELLED - Board of Directors
  • Large Locals Meeting
  • Ethnic Minority Affairs Committee (EMAC) Monthly Meeting

Copyright (C) 2023 · Brookline Educators Union · Part of the MTASITES NETWORK