Brookline Educators Union

  • Home
    • About the BEU
    • Leadership
      • Officers
      • Consultants / Committee Chairs
      • Executive Board
      • Grievance Team
      • Building Representative Council
      • Health & Safety Committee
    • Contact
  • Negotiations Blog
  • News
    • BEU Newsletter
    • Solidarity Bulletins
    • Outside Press
    • Galleries
  • Parents & Community
    • Information
    • Allies
    • Community Events
  • Member Discussion
  • Documents
    • Contracts
    • Member Information and Forms
    • BEU Bylaws
  • First-Time Login?

Brookline has no excuse for its failure to agree to a fair contract

April 26, 2022

 

 

On March 25, 2022, the Brookline Educators Union (BEU) submitted an on-the-record proposal to the Brookline School Committee (BSC) in lieu of a mediation session that had been canceled that day. The concept behind the proposal was to create more stability in our schools by settling the current contract for Units A and B (9/1/2020-8/31/2023) AND the successor contract (9/01/2023-8/31/2026) for Units A, B and Para at the same time.  In addition to the value of the substance of the proposals, the BEU sees many benefits for both sides to enter into the non-traditional agreement between the BEU and the Public Schools of Brookline. However, on April 8, 2022, the School Committee rejected the proposal outright. In an all to familiar approach, they showed no interest in exploring the idea with us with an eye toward working creatively with us. 

 

The BEU and the BSC have been engaged in collective bargaining for the better part of the last four years. For three years in a row, teachers have started school with an expired contract.  It is past time to introduce more stability than this into the school system.

 

TIMELINE — THE CONTRACTS ARE EXPIRED AND DO NOT MEET CURRENT NEEDS

 

  • In the winter of the 2018-2019 school year when Andrew Bott was superintendent, the two sides entered into bargaining of a successor contract to the 2016-2019 Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) with an end date that coming August. Protracted negotiations were still underway during the following 2019-2020 school year when Covid hit in March.
  • While the BSC and the BEU were bargaining the first COVID MOA, both sides agreed to a one year, money only contract that covered that current 2019-2020 school year.  
  • A second Covid MOA was negotiated, now for the 2020-2021 school year, and now with a second another interim superintendent, Jim Marini, in the district. The MOA was settled in December of 2020 only after the BEU was forced to engage in a one day strike to get the district to agree to six foot distancing in classrooms.  
  • Bargaining resumed for the successor 2020-2023 CBA but was sidelined when the BSC triggered a clause in the COVID MOA that would cut distancing in the 2nd MOA to three feet. Sessions on Covid matters concluded with no agreement in March of 2021. The district implemented three foot distancing as the original second COVID MOA allowed them to impose a change after a limited number of sessions.  
  • Negotiations resumed for the 2020-2023 CBA in May and June of 2021 with several marathon sessions.  During these sessions, the current rate of inflation was raised as a key concern by the BEU.  In an effort to get an agreement, the BEU consolidated over 15 pages of non-wage proposals for improving schools into five proposals addressing pay, hiring and retention of staff of color, preparation time, and a joint labor-management committee to analyze the “teacher day” as defined in the CBA. The BSC only countered with wage proposals that didn’t come close to keeping up with Cost of Living increases as published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics and rejected out of hand the proposals dealing with staff retention and unsustainable workday obligations.
  • A paraprofessional agreement was reached, however, and ratified on June 30, 2021.
  • In October 2021, with a new superintendent, Dr. Guillory, a 3rd Covid MOA was settled with the school committee with CBA negotiations suspended because the District had said they would not negotiate COVID and the CBA simultaneously. 
  • In November 2021, CBA negotiations began again. While the BEU submitted the same proposals that had been on the table in May and June, the BSC added completely new  proposals that significantly curtailed union rights, exercise of professional judgment by teachers, and lengthened the contractual workday for elementary (k-8) teachers.  When the BEU wouldn’t accept uncompensated added work time or pay in general that didn’t even keep up with inflation, the BSC filed for mediation, which the BEU opposed. Initially the Board of Labor Relations agreed with the BEU that the two sides had not met enough times for there to be a mediator assigned, the BSC forced the issue by being unwavering on pay increases that were half the rate of projected Cost of Living over the life of the contract and by refusing to rescind the late-added items of extending the school day and diminishing the rights educators and the BEU.

 

EXCELLENT SCHOOLS WITH FAIR CONTRACTS ARE FOUNDATIONS OF THE TOWN’S FISCAL HEALTH

 

As the sides prepared for mediation, the BEU formed a data team that looked closely at the town’s financial picture and demographic trends in order to see if Brookline was as “broke” as the school committee claimed in negotiations sessions.  We also looked at the stability of school staffing because the core of schools is its educators.

 

In regard to town revenue, even aside from the $25+ million dollars that the town has spent to acquire property this year, the BEU found that the town of Brookline has the ability, capacity, and obligation to increase ad/or reallocate revenue to fund what the BEU has demanded at the bargaining table.

  

  • Over the last five years, the town of Brookline has amassed an annual excess of $5.9 million in tax receipts than estimates used for the purpose of fiscal planning.   
  • Brookline’s tax rate is well below the state average. It is 31st lowest in the state.  
  • Thus, while tax bills may be high due to high property values, the cost of owning high priced houses in Brookline is well below the cost in other districts.  
  • “Living well” costs less in Brookline than it does elsewhere, and because of this, there is an excess capacity to tax under Prop 2.5 of close to half a BILLION dollars in the town of Brookline.  
  • Residents in town have seen their median household income increase almost 14% between fiscal years 2016-2019 while teacher cost of living (COLA) increases during that time averaged less than half of that.  In fact, income growth in town from FY2010 through FY2019 increased almost 42.5% while salary growth for teachers with a masters degree at top step only increased about 23%.  

 

BROOKLINE EDUCATORS ARE LEAVING

 

Clearly there is an ability and an argument to increase revenue in town, but there is also a need to weigh how existing revenue is allocated.   

 

It is well known that property values on which revenue depends are driven by the quality of public schools, and that quality is first and foremost a reflection of the quality of teaching.  Our classroom educators and related service providers are our students’ greatest source of stability in a school system that has had 6 superintendents in 7 years and an unusually high turnover of principals and central administrators.

 

In the absence of a contract that is more fair, Brookline’s educators, including much needed teachers, paraprofessionals, and related service providers, are leaving the district.  Before COVID hit, Brookline had the lowest rate of retention among peer districts with just under 85%.  For reference, Newton was at 89% and Wellesley, Needham, Lincoln / Sudbury, Lexington, and Concord / Carlisle were over 90% staff retention rates.  Through February of this year, Brookline remains among the lowest retention rates of peer districts at just under 83%. Weston and Wellesley are comparable in these numbers, but both have CBA’s where top earners make more than Brookline teachers.  Districts such as Newton and Concord Carlisle pay their veteran teachers more than Brookline as well.  

 

SETTLING LONG-TERM, FAIR CONTRACTS IS GOOD FOR BROOKLINE

On April 19, 2022, the Select Board released $3.5 million of federal Covid emergency funds to the schools.  Now it is time to agree to a fair contract.  Past time.

 

All budgets and all contracts commit to costs that stretch into the future and it is past time that the first priority be a commitment to the teaching staff. The BEU’s current proposal makes this planning easier than usual by giving the town even more time to reallocate and/or increase revenue. This includes using federal emergency Covid funds as a bridge to shifting its priorities to providing such supports. 

 

The union’s idea that the School Committee rejected proposed settling two contracts for a total of six years (two of the years are already in the rear view mirror) which would have begun to erase the labor strife and uncertainty that teachers, administrators, and district leaders have endured for too many years. The cost of this labor peace proposed by the BEU would have been less than 3% per year with increases can be back loaded to allow time for much needed overrides and / or a true needs assessment and stakeholder review of where money is being spent and why by town leaders.  These needs in the buildings have been identified by educators and outside reviews such as the most recent assessment of the Special Education Program Review which noted significant shortcomings in staffing levels and opportunities for all students, general and special ed, to access adequate academic and social emotional support.  

 

Brookline schools have been a shining light in the state for a long time.  In order to begin the work to build them back to where they should be, accept this contract proposal and let us get back to work with job security and retention fears allayed.  The BEU proposals help provide the foundation on which educators can address the needs of the district and make it everything it once was.

 

—  Eric Schiff, Chair, for the BEU Negotiating Team

Filed Under: Contract Campaign News, Featured News, Negotiations Tagged With:

Log In


Lost your password?

Need Help Signing In

You can retrieve your password by following this link Retrieve Password

BEU Calendar

« March 2023 » loading...
S M T W T F S
26
27
28
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
1

MTA Info

Slideshow

71572985_10156527182556481_2961474637441007616_n
75340992_10156527182486481_5197738364710682624_n
75610779_10156527182431481_7222238012191539200_n
76705093_10156527182361481_580951325294985216_n
77200154_10156527182296481_2095998504928280576_n
75299781_10156527182241481_4811008913694523392_n
75627614_10156527182181481_4009689993332129792_n
78319007_10156527182086481_2934541198175502336_n
76779615_10156527182006481_4600587200164265984_n
78179402_10156527181926481_6567703352971362304_n
78045864_10156527181821481_7340512297602777088_n
75464267_10156527181751481_1819895600297017344_n
77318258_10156527181666481_4888432674231812096_n
77276017_10156527181611481_8390125678233649152_n
76647963_10156527181511481_4822376360687173632_n
75439241_10156527181426481_2614144089662160896_n
75569719_10156527181366481_7217270594750906368_n
75453544_10156527181311481_1311577609405988864_n
75394814_10156527181261481_6034144964563173376_n
78202874_10156527181176481_6314301665486831616_n
75593855_10156527181031481_4933908049954865152_n
77387958_10156527180966481_9190925324165054464_n
76695181_10156527180921481_6518092580872257536_n
75552940_10156527180771481_4429132496549969920_n
74328752_10156527180721481_7089642738152374272_n
73106913_10156527180641481_721401527582851072_n
77095163_10156527180566481_5310595171648274432_n
74989167_10156527180506481_8603826809747800064_n
76602147_10156527180416481_6754796595151110144_n
74185994_10156527180341481_1371592158095605760_n
74604757_10156527180196481_5602870573769162752_n
74169784_10156527180131481_8881237153963573248_n
75572083_10156527180061481_2332243301303844864_n
76686447_10156527179986481_338396586306437120_n
75380335_10156527179921481_8217248386961637376_n
75402150_10156527179841481_8823101730775367680_n
76697317_10156527179776481_4637793715870498816_n
75486021_10156527179706481_6981821080289673216_n
76756802_10156527179626481_7435463257034326016_n
77362202_10156527179541481_4601157086489870336_n
75472913_10156527179481481_1033752457248768000_n
76635068_10156527179276481_7071649878903881728_n
75102848_10156527179211481_3946248649150824448_n
73458832_10156527179161481_3635898341021188096_n
76710902_10156527179106481_4160953548881788928_n
75278253_10156527179051481_7460698023849361408_n
76697338_10156527179001481_8706999612189179904_n
75497654_10156527178911481_5192524471981834240_n
77015067_10156527178866481_4799429260957712384_n
75439500_10156527178781481_4959225082573488128_n
76654340_10156527178716481_1592310935458938880_n
76613075_10156527178631481_1142714385978884096_n
75271485_10156527178581481_5183944600498208768_n
73399913_10156527178516481_7474916663406624768_n
77380332_10156527178441481_790633273658179584_n
74505859_10156527178356481_6070150246636191744_n
75282174_10156527178276481_2620985903845212160_n
76769694_10156527178216481_246958549345763328_n
76602207_10156527178106481_106235659584274432_n
76195570_10156527178061481_4728173563083751424_n
77173198_10156527177961481_4228313969116315648_n
75341177_10156527177926481_6816645769185984512_n
77086468_10156527177861481_2482849572238393344_n
78549613_10156527177821481_1522192828392800256_n
76771526_10156527177691481_5267226760851750912_n
78228830_10156527177621481_8046835449139822592_n
76765485_10156527177541481_7603655834203062272_n
76905575_10156527177496481_1331044991056740352_n
72650894_10156527177446481_426676447915016192_n
75439387_10156529791796481_7605026216533295104_n
74906685_10156529791711481_4507321195057643520_n
75472800_10156529791621481_8273844695734419456_n
78324959_10156529791546481_4421978292215611392_n
76200953_10156529791461481_7810043851887869952_n
76604994_10156529791346481_7297806789238587392_n
76184068_10156529791251481_407966642660704256_n
76702356_10156529791141481_7145824419372335104_n
77050195_10156529791071481_6171278326817095680_n
76262118_10156529790946481_1521840576650018816_n
76646858_10156529790816481_7354573844436221952_n
76654443_10156529790711481_3955329172087242752_n
75653344_10156529790616481_8802692329652617216_n
77429104_10156529790511481_7189871576735547392_n
78378284_10156529790386481_7367155251050184704_n
77223478_10156529790331481_4072090100001931264_n
75540050_10156529790256481_2804853917643440128_n
75388427_10156529790171481_9131014529000407040_n
74458866_10156529790111481_5162929256799404032_n
76638469_10156529789951481_6601920893562126336_n
75594549_10156529789851481_2305702984689909760_n
78282726_10156529789681481_7478362043221803008_n
75594656_10156529789581481_411080395166056448_n
75429550_10156529789446481_7820025536272400384_n
78077156_10156529789326481_2266808070094979072_n
75302638_10156529789251481_1403549777089527808_n
75341222_10156529789091481_2310894792696922112_n
76640157_10156529788896481_5187039085780271104_n
74638368_10156529788741481_2188673874722291712_n
75310395_10156529788646481_155301962974232576_n
76204363_10156529788536481_5335884725066137600_n
77019497_10156529788476481_5122369432491917312_n
76605039_677150779359738_1323139730086297600_o-1
73513511_677150702693079_7154439286249488384_o
75543579_677150726026410_1967170754726330368_o-1
76757017_677150712693078_1666987196827041792_o
75439479_677152486026234_8272101604732174336_o-1
76652219_677151109359705_9001966794868523008_o-1
75424699_677151762692973_6641199739578613760_o-1
78104674_677152879359528_4127313814536323072_o-1
78156053_677153036026179_5985210482309464064_o-1
76901297_677150822693067_1623452734004920320_o-1
76769616_677151392693010_6148900232944943104_o-1
75594484_677151002693049_3594900335560228864_o
75580222_677151459359670_9125232089975750656_o-1
75449997_677152402692909_8725789007482454016_o
75485989_677151679359648_8845943724065161216_o-1
77317549_677151639359652_1249825755035074560_o-1
74522905_677152276026255_3648899829796438016_o
75462303_677151902692959_1485568976539877376_o
74649831_677152732692876_8738859679590907904_o-1
75627592_677152499359566_922905609106358272_o-1
75220761_677152439359572_2063443309954596864_o-1
75418843_677151629359653_1948648334600175616_o-1
77271149_677150926026390_1942882027472683008_o-1
77092671_677151212693028_3350264903960100864_o-1
75311432_677151326026350_646064824798674944_o-1
76258126_677151972692952_5463950530889908224_o-1
75323307_677152259359590_5835573615558393856_o-1
77426044_677151579359658_3781059156065124352_o-1
77303019_677151082693041_7258404497272078336_o-1
76622735_677151052693044_2451552738257928192_o-1
76693193_677151302693019_1328326912413532160_o-1
76695115_677151406026342_3487830601917005824_o-1
75317334_677150902693059_6471376011140268032_o-1
75398228_677153009359515_6207596827970109440_o-1
75349034_677151912692958_6976518741299298304_o-1
76993623_677152322692917_1402407135400165376_o-1
75299806_677152766026206_3274224732777480192_o-1
75481736_677151126026370_7359079823475474432_o-1
72473196_677152129359603_8274354491172585472_o-1
76197817_677152839359532_7247743241687138304_o-1
75576364_677152616026221_1383416542363910144_o-1
76720817_677151496026333_6749275161289031680_o-1
78058586_677151546026328_4808466159911305216_o-1
73250462_677152866026196_4072139462061064192_o-1
76972165_677152139359602_3188504963735093248_o-1
76756947_677151832692966_4240348420235067392_o-1
75231815_677152626026220_6538212453954617344_o-1
76967208_677152186026264_6984797290762338304_o-1
76267355_677152756026207_43375828205043712_o-1
77261230_677152602692889_6164321721043124224_o-1
75534259_677150932693056_5577135288645320704_o-1
76898914_677152369359579_5248627134393483264_o-1
69855955_677153019359514_8036579247625601024_o-1
76913759_677151282693021_5167290113188691968_o-1
76620889_677151786026304_8675767237077893120_o-1
78606874_677151029359713_2293491220141309952_o-1
76686507_10219715883508795_442342207983190016_o-1
IMG_1595
IMG_1594
IMG_1591
IMG_1592
IMG_1596
IMG_1597
IMG_1600
IMG_1598
IMG_1601
IMG_1603
IMG_1604
IMG_1605
IMG_1608
IMG_1609
IMG_1610
IMG_1611
IMG_1613
IMG_1614
IMG_1615
IMG_1616
IMG_1617
IMG_1621
IMG_1619
IMG_1622
IMG_1623
IMG_1627
IMG_1629
IMG_1630
IMG_1631
IMG_1632
IMG_1633

Categories

Archives

Latest Local Union News

  • BACK TO SCHOOL!
  • School Committee Forces BEU to Strike
  • Without Contract, Brookline Educators Authorize Strike for Monday, May 16
  • BEU submits counter-offer to School Committee on May 10, 2022

Follow Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

BEU Latest Tweets

  • Congrats to BEU member & Brookline Middle School Science teacher Mark Goldner! @BrooklinePublic @BeuBrookline https://t.co/kH91JdejG3 March 25, 2023 11:15 pm
  • I just signed a @theactionnet petition: Support Malden's Public School Educators. Sign here: https://t.co/5Z69rUhic9 September 16, 2022 11:09 am
  • Take the Pledge - NO CONTRACT NO COFFEE https://t.co/2l0fsbEf7y August 26, 2022 7:03 pm

RSS MTA News

  • Union News: The power of democratized, open bargaining March 28, 2023
  • The latest news about upcoming public education campaigns, actions and events March 21, 2023
  • Full steam ahead for Higher Ed for All March 15, 2023

RSS MTA Events

  • 2023 ESP Conference
  • "Raising Multicultural Kids" in the Classroom: Educator Training (PreK-6)
  • Using Anti-Bias Literature & Social-Emotional Learning to Promote Equity & Inclusion in Your Class

Copyright (C) 2023 · Brookline Educators Union · Part of the MTASITES NETWORK